Independent education resourceInformation here does not replace care from a qualified health professional.
Peptide Therapy GuideClear peptide education

Educational guide

The Role of Chromatographic Separations in Bottom-up Characterization of Bio-therapeutics by “Peptide Mapping” Analysis

Martin Samonig Applications Scientist Thermo Fisher Scientific Alexander Schwahn European Support Expert Thermo Fisher Scientific Ken Cook Ph.D. EU Bio-Separations Expert Thermo Fisher Scientific Mike Oliver Product Manager Thermo Fisher Scientific Remco Swart

Written by Peptide Therapy Guide Editorial Team
For education only

This guide cannot diagnose a condition or recommend a personal treatment plan. Discuss medical questions with a qualified professional.

Martin Samonig Applications Scientist Thermo Fisher Scientific

Alexander Schwahn European Support Expert Thermo Fisher Scientific

Ken Cook Ph.D. EU Bio-Separations Expert Thermo Fisher Scientific

Mike Oliver Product Manager Thermo Fisher Scientific

Remco Swart Ph.D. Director Product Manager Thermo Fisher Scientific

Rowan Moore Vertical Marketing Manager Thermo Fisher Scientific

Kelly Broster Pharma & Biopharma Vertical Marketing Manager Thermo Fisher Scientific

This is the third article in a series of four, describing the characterization of protein-based bio-therapeutics by bottom-up analysis at peptide level (peptide mapping analysis). This article summarizes the requirements for chromatographic separations.

Reproducibility and associated confidence in results is of paramount importance in ensuring accurate peptide mapping. Improvements in reproducible sample preparation, as shown with the Thermo Scientific™ SMART Digest™ kit, need to be complemented across the entire workflow. The chromatographic separation stage has a significant impact on the quality and of results that can be obtained, as well as throughput. Both instrument and column considerations are critical to success in this area.

Peptide mapping has typically employed “long” gradients to separate highly complex peptide-mapping samples, with run times often taking hours to complete. However, the duration of separation is often at odds with the needs of high-throughput biopharmaceutical environments. Fast peptide-mapping achieved during the cell-line development/clone selection phase can expedite the transfer of candidate compounds into the drug process development phase. The advantages of an increase in speed must not come at the expense of the quality of the analytical results. By ensuring this, the method could also be transferred into the QC environment.

In order to achieve these requirements, the column and UHPLC system employed must provide high levels of reproducibility and robustness coupled with the ability to deliver fast and efficient separations.

Column Considerations for Peptide Mapping

Protein digest samples are often very complex and consequently gradient conditions and columns with high peak capacity are required to achieve adequate separation. To achieve high peak capacity, small particle sizes and long columns are typically employed along with long run times and shallow gradients. These long run-times are undesirable due to throughput considerations, as well as from a sensitivity perspective due to in-column peak dilution.

Sensitivity is of particular importance for the identification of low-level peptides carrying potential modifications and also when peptide mapping is performed with ultra-violet (UV) detection alone. The risk is that low-level components will not be detected. Therefore, high peak capacity is required while balancing a total run time which is reasonably short.

The use of elevated temperatures has a major impact on the peak capacity of peptides separated by reversed phase (RP) chromatography. Temperature increases from 40 °C up to 80 °C can lead to >20% increase in peak capacity for a 30-minute gradient. Peptides have increased diffusion rates at higher temperatures, ultimately producing narrower peaks, and thus delivering higher peak capacity peptide maps. The use of mobile phase pre-heating can also reduce peak broadening and retention time variation through the prevention of thermal differences inside the column.

The choice of stationary phase also has an impact on the quality of data achieved for peptide mapping. Peptide separations normally employ RP columns with silica-based C18 stationary phases with near-zero silanophilic activities which result in superior separation with minimal peak broadening. The use of formic acid as a mobile-phase additive also provides additional advantages for MS detection. Compared to TFA, formic acid causes lower ion suppression and consequently results in higher sensitivity for MS-based methods. In contrast, UV-only methods benefit from the use of TFA as an ion-pairing reagent, often resulting in improved peak separations compared to formic acid.

UHPLC System Considerations for Peptide Mapping

Proteins and peptides by their nature may have an affinity to interact with metal surfaces and might adsorb, therefore, the UHPLC system used should be “biocompatible”. Reproducibility and robustness are critical for peptide-mapping experiments and the UHPLC systems used must be capable of delivering highly stable, precise flow-rates and gradients in order to deliver highly reproducible retention times (RTs) (Figure 1).

Highly reproducible peptide maps and retention times also enable confidence in direct comparisons of samples for monitoring of conditional differences (Figure 2). The ability to compare reduced and non-reduced peptide samples provides information on disulfide bond locations within the molecule, resulting in a greater understanding of the protein structure.

Figure 1. Retention time repeatability of a peptide separation

Chromatographic reproducibility is also of particular importance where UV detection is used for standalone detection, and assignments are made solely based on analyte elution time. Confidence in the reproducibility of the protein digestion and separation allows the facile transfer of methods from LC-MS platforms to LC-UV (Figure 3).

There are a number of other considerations which can have a dramatic impact on the results obtained, and the applicability of the system to throughput requirements. The choice of the autosampler can affect reproducibility; this can be mitigated by using systems which offer sample loop pre-compression to minimize pressure changes. Does the column oven offer a wide temperature range and high stability? Does the sample manager offer sample capacities which meet throughput requirements?

Figure 2. Comparison of reduced and non-reduced forms of rituximab

The choice of pump also needs to be considered based on the application requirement. For high-throughput environments requiring fast peptide-map run times, a binary high-pressure pumping system can offer lower gradient delay volumes and therefore faster re-equilibration and re-injection times. The ability to increase flow rates by high-pressure capabilities allows faster run times. By varying the pressure and flow rate, gradients can be reduced from >30 minutes to just 5 minutes. A 1,000-bar pressure system would be capable of achieving the 13-minute gradient, and a 1,500-bar system would have the pressure capabilities to achieve the 5-minute separation shown in Figure 4.

Figure 3. Overlaid chromatograms of the total ion current (TIC) and the UV trace at 214 nm of a rituximab sample digested with a Thermo Scientific™ SMART Digest™ kit

For all five gradient times tested, from 30 minutes down to 5 minutes, very good separation is achieved while maintaining sequence coverage of 100% for both the light and heavy chain of rituximab.

For separations where throughput is not as important and system flexibility is needed, a quaternary pumping UHPLC system is also appropriate. Both options need to deliver low dispersion, robust and reliable high flow rates, and generate low baseline noise.

In the next article in the series, we will investigate the role of mass spectrometry in the peptide-mapping workflow.

Figure 4. Reduction in chromatographic run-time for rituximab while maintaining 100% sequence coverage

Additional Resources

1. Technical Note: High Resolution Peptide Mapping for Biopharmaceutical Analysis

Martin Samonig is application scientist, LC-MS; Alexander Schwahn is European support expert for biopharma industry; Ken Cook is EU bio-separations expert; Mike Oliver is product manager, sample preparation and Accucore LC products; Remco Swart is director, product manager, HPLC & LC-MS solutions; Rowan Moore is pharma & biopharma vertical marketing manager; Kelly Broster is pharma & biopharma vertical marketing manager at Thermo Fisher Scientific.

Connected reading

Helpful context for this guide

Source-derived material selected through this article’s indexed topics.

Related questions

01So, how can this definition challenge be overcome?

To precisely define self and non-self peptides and, in turn, self-similarity, we must first improve our understanding of the adaptive immune cascade and its constituent components. In brief, the fundamental unit of adaptive immune recognition comprises the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules (called the human leukocyte antigen [HLA] in humans), the peptide being presented (and, in turn, identified as self or non-self), and the T cell receptor.

Source: www.news-medical.net ↗
02What was done in this study?

In the study, published in Scientific Reports, the researchers built on their earlier discovery of the peptide called AC253. This compound was tested in mice with AD. It was found to block the attachment of beta-amyloid to a brain cell receptor called the amylin receptor, and thus inhibit its toxic effects, as shown by an improvement in spatial memory. However, it is difficult to administer this compound because it doesn’t cross the blood-brain barrier in large amounts, and is quickly broken down in the blood. The dosage must therefore be massively increased, pushing up the amounts required for efficacy and increasing the difficulty of administration, besides enhancing the chances of an immune reaction. One way out is to convert the formulation into a pill rather than an injectable form. The complex structure of AC253 makes this difficult as well. Instead, the team devised an ingenious solution. They cleaved the compound into smaller amylin peptides, or chains of 12-14 amino acids, and tested each for its anti-amyloid activity in old mice which showed signs of AD. In this way, they found two short peptides that had the same effects as the larger compound. In particular, the researchers identified a segment that was common to both peptides, namely, SQELHRLQTY.

Source: www.news-medical.net ↗
03A peptide identified in a fungus found in northern European pine forests possesses as much power as penicillin as well as vancomycin, according to an international team of researchers.

Reporting in the October 13 issue of Nature, a team from Denmark-based biotech company Novozymes, and researchers from Georgetown University Medical Center and the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, say they have isolated "plectasin," the first defensin ever found in fungi. The research was performed at Novozymes laboratories in Denmark. Defensins are peptides, miniature protein molecules that are produced by a wide range of animals to protect themselves against infection. Humans have defensins in their white blood cells and in their skin, for example, but it is believed that this new fungal defensin, plectasin, is more potent and targets certain bacteria more specifically. Indeed, when plectasin was tested in the laboratory and in animals, it proved to be highly effective against the bacteria Streptococcus pneumoniae, and Streptococcus pyogenes, including strains that are now resistant to conventional antibiotics. These bacteria are responsible for such diseases as meningitis, community-acquired pneumonia, strep throat, life-threatening sepsis, and flesh destroying skin infections. The discovery of plectasin has implications for the development of defensins as a treatment against many common, and deadly, infections, and may initiate a new era of antibiotic discovery and development, said study co-author Michael Zasloff, M.D., Ph.D., Professor in the Departments of Surgery and Pediatrics at Georgetown University Medical Center. Zasloff says that the field of antibiotic development has not changed much since 1929 when Alexander Fleming realized that the fungal "bread mold" Penicillium, which had landed by chance in a Petri dish produced a substance that eliminated colonies of staphylococcal bacteria. "Most antibiotics used by humans are produced by fungi and certain soil bacteria," he said. "Using our existing tools of discovery, we have failed to uncover any new classes of antibiotics from these sources over the past decade. However, by utilizing a new genetic approach that allowed the team to discover plectasin, we now know that a whole class of antibiotics has been overlooked." "This finding (plectasin), and the existence of about 200,000 additional species of fungi, opens up a vast universe to explore for novel peptide antibiotics," said co-author Robert Lehrer, M.D., Distinguished Professor of Medicine at the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA. Plectasin, if proven safe and effective in humans, could be on the market by 2012, said Lehrer. Zasloff and Lehrer are known internationally as experts in antimicrobial peptides - the class of antibiotics that plectasin falls within - and in this study they collaborated with Novozymes, a Danish biotech company that led the research. Zasloff and Lehrer are the only two scientists from U.S. universities on the team of 20 researchers who co-authored the research paper. All life forms have to defend themselves against microbial invaders - bacteria, fungi, viruses - and to do this, they produce antimicrobial defensin peptides. In humans, defensins are made by specific white blood cells and immune cells that later engulf foreign invaders, and by the skin and mucous membranes, in order to kill microbes before they invade protective barriers. Researchers believe that fungi have a similar system of defense, especially since these plant-like organisms live off rotting matter, said Zasloff. "They must compete with other organisms, like bacteria and viruses, which also want to consume the same meal. In addition, they need to defend themselves from being eaten by the microbes which surround them." But he said no one had been able to find defensins in fungi using traditional research techniques, which involved growing fungi in liquid cultures and then testing the culture to see if it contained any antibiotic molecule. The research team instead used the latest genetic science to search for the defensins they thought fungi must have. Selecting the Pseudoplectania nigrella species of fungus may have been serendipitous, Lehrer said, but the Novozymes team used state-of-the-art biotechnology to intercept ,and interpret its genetic messages and exhibited tremendous skill in producing plectasin efficiently, economically, and in large amounts." "I started working on antimicrobial peptides over three decades ago, said Lehrer, and my laboratory first described human defensins in 1985. So, the discovery of plectasin makes me feel like a grandfather." Further examination revealed that this defensin, plectasin, resembles defensins found in spiders, scorpions, dragonflies and mussels - thus suggesting that the defensins found in insects, molluscs and fungi arose from a common ancestral gene, the researchers say. Based on this information, the scientists now believe that defensins appeared in living things more than a billion years ago. The investigators then turned to the National Center for Antimicrobials and Infection Control, the Danish equivalent of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control, to test plectasin in the laboratory for antimicrobial activity against a broad spectrum of bacteria. It showed potent activity against several species of Gram-positive bacteria, and was especially active against S. pneumoniae (the leading cause of pneumonia), including all known clinical strains and those that are now resistant to conventional antibiotics. "That is important because increasing bacterial resistance to conventional antibiotics threatens the future of many antibiotics in current use," Zasloff said. "In mouse studies, plectasin showed extremely low toxicity, and was as effective as vancomycin and penicillin in curing the animals of experimental peritonitis (inflammation of the lining of the abdominal cavity, which can be deadly) and pneumonia caused by S. pneumoniae, the researchers report. "Although the precise mechanism by which plectasin exerts its antimicrobial activity is still under investigation, it may work by a mechanism that is very different from traditional antibiotics, Zasloff said. "As a group, defensins exhibit activity against many types of bacteria, fungi, protozoa, and even viruses. It is entirely possible that fungal defensins will be discovered that could be developed against all of these human pathogens," Zasloff added.

Source: www.news-medical.net ↗
04What is nisin?

Some bacterial species produce antimicrobial peptides known as bacteriocins that have been used in the food industry as preservatives. For example, nisin, which is produced by Lactococcus lactis, has broad-spectrum bactericidal activity and has been used as a food preservative throughout the world. Nisin is effective in controlling Gram-positive bacteria such as Clostridioides difficile. In combination with other compounds like ethylene diamine tetra-acetic acid and cinnamaldehyde, nisin has been effective in controlling enterotoxigenic Gram-negative bacteria such as Escherichia coli. Previous studies have used chicken and mouse models to demonstrate the in vivo efficacy of nisin on the microbiome, whereas nisin efficacy has been proven in ex vivo experiments on the human microbiome. To date, no studies have assessed the in vivo effects of nisin in large mammals.

Source: www.news-medical.net ↗
05What roles does the system play?

The endogenous opioids and their receptors are widely distributed throughout the central and peripheral nervous systems, particularly the parts of these systems that regulate pain, emotion, reward, stress responses, motivation, drug addiction, and autonomic control. The differential expression and location of the various receptor subtypes across different neurons account for the wide range of opioid-related behaviors. The activation of µ-opioid receptors is mainly known for playing a role in pain relief. Still, research has also indicated it may be involved in behaviors related to survival, such as appetite and reproduction. The activity of µ-opioid receptors is also known to play a critical role in responses to social stimuli by modulating responses to social rejection or social acceptance, for example. Activation of the δ-opioid receptors and κ-opioid receptors is also known to be involved in pain modulation. Also, studies have shown that NOP activation is involved in pain mechanisms and several behaviors related to psychological stress. Alterations in the endogenous opioid system are suspected to be involved in Parkinson's disease, seizures, neuroprotective mechanisms, and depression.

Source: www.news-medical.net ↗
comparison

Comparisons

Side-by-side pages for commonly compared peptides and research compounds.

Source: peptideuniv.com
Research context

Read sources and limitations before applying a claim.

Longevity, Performance & Obesity Research

A research peptide formulation developed to investigate metabolic regulation, mitochondrial function, and nutrient-sensing pathways.

Source: mypeptidematch.com ↗
P

About the author

Peptide Therapy Guide Editorial Team

Editorial team for Peptide Therapy Guide.

View all articles →